Blog › Italy vs France: Mbappé Is Back, and Zidane Faces His First Real Test

Blog

Italy vs France: Mbappé Is Back, and Zidane Faces His First Real Test

2026-11-11 · by the Footalytics team

Zinedine Zidane has been France coach for 48 days: three wins, one draw — 1-0 away to Turkey, two wins over Belgium, 1-1 at home to Italy. He is the

Contents
  1. Forty-eight days into the Zidane era, someone can finally test him
  2. The model's numbers: hosts narrowly ahead — but read them with a discount
  3. Why this one is worth staying up for
  4. What would change this call
  5. Talk about it
  6. The model and the method

Forty-eight days into the Zidane era, someone can finally test him

Zinedine Zidane has been France coach for 48 days: three wins, one draw — 1-0 away to Turkey, two wins over Belgium, 1-1 at home to Italy. He is the first France coach to win his debut since Aimé Jacquet in 1994, and the first to go unbeaten through his first four games since Raymond Domenech in 2004. But honestly, none of those four games was a real test. The debut win over Turkey came from a Mbappé goal — and Mbappé limped off with a knee injury five minutes after scoring, missing the rest of the window.

Italy on 12 November is the first real test. France lead Group A1 on 10 points; Italy are second on seven. An Italy win levels the points; a France win or draw all but seals top spot. And the biggest part: Mbappé is back.

Ask the AI: Who is more likely to win, Italy or France?

The model's numbers: hosts narrowly ahead — but read them with a discount

Footalytics' live read gives Italy 41%, draw 28%, France 32%, most likely score 1-1 (13%), both teams to score 56%, over 2.5 goals 51%. The honest caveat first: the national teams have no rating on file, so this read uses a neutral default — a rough sketch, not a pick. The official prediction is published 24–48 hours before kick-off and locked one hour out.

The model leans slightly to Italy on home advantage. France's ceiling is higher, though — and the difference is Mbappé.

Why this one is worth staying up for

  • Mbappé's form: eight goals in seven club games (La Liga and Champions League) since returning — the knee looks like a non-issue. On 67 international goals, he is chasing Ronaldo's 146 — and Ronaldo retired from Portugal duty on 5 November.
  • The quality of Zidane's start: without Mbappé for three games, France still beat Belgium twice and drew with Italy. The system does not depend on one man; Mbappé's return is an addition, not a rescue.
  • Italy's home and desperation: Italy must win to take control of the group race, in Milan, with their backs to the wall. They drew 1-1 in France on 2 October — they are not afraid of this team.
  • Head-to-head: France lead the last five meetings 3-1-1, but Italy's win was a 3-1 away victory in September 2024. They have the memory of beating France on French soil.
  • The stakes: a draw all but seals top spot for France; a defeat leaves Italy fighting for second. Both sides have everything to lose, for different reasons.

What would change this call

  • Mbappé doesn't start: if Zidane eases him back from the bench, France's first-half threat drops a level and Italy's window to strike early opens.
  • Italy score first: the Milan crowd plus a lead to protect would test a French system that has not yet had to chase a game.
  • The temptation of the draw: France can live with a point; Italy cannot. If it is still 1-1 after 70 minutes, the last 20 could be more electric — or more cagey — than the first 70, depending on who blinks first.

Talk about it

The model and the method

Footalytics predictions come from a Dixon-Coles Poisson model with Elo-style ratings. Every official pick is locked before kick-off and graded in public afterwards. See the latest numbers on the accuracy dashboard: 252 matches settled, 58.7% on win/draw/loss, Brier 0.581, 87.5% in the high-confidence tier (32 matches). The method is explained here. Match page: https://footalytics.farvor.com/match/nations-league-401861151-italy-vs-france

Try it on the next match

The model reads every fixture the same way — ask it about the next one, or check the public record first.

💬 Ask AI