Blog › Italy 3-1 France: A 64-Year Home Hoodoo Ends, and So Does Zidane's Unbeaten Start

Blog

Italy 3-1 France: A 64-Year Home Hoodoo Ends, and So Does Zidane's Unbeaten Start

2026-11-13 · by the Footalytics team

Italy came from behind to beat France 3-1 at San Siro — their first home win over France since 1962, and Zinedine Zidane's first defeat as France coach.

Contents
  1. Ten minutes in, France thought the script was written
  2. The model's numbers: the direction was right, the scoreline was not
  3. Why this one is worth remembering
  4. What would change this call
  5. Talk about it
  6. The model and the method

Ten minutes in, France thought the script was written

In the 10th minute, Gianluigi Donnarumma gave the ball away playing out from the back, Michael Olise punished him, and France led 1-0. San Siro went quiet for a second — the script looked exactly like everyone had imagined: France had Zidane, France had Olise, Italy could only wait.

Then the script was torn up. Francesco Pio Esposito levelled in the 26th minute; in the 63rd, substitute Federico Dimarco had barely been on the pitch before teeing up Davide Frattesi for the lead; in the 75th, Pio Esposito converted a penalty to complete his brace, 3-1. In between, his brother Sebastiano fired a penalty wide, and France hit the woodwork twice — the scoreline could have been worse.

It is Italy's first home win over France in 64 years (the last was a friendly in Florence in May 1962), and Zinedine Zidane's first defeat as France coach. Italy go top of Group A1 on 10 points, level with France but ahead on head-to-head.

Ask the AI: After Italy's 3-1 win over France, who is more likely to top the group?

The model's numbers: the direction was right, the scoreline was not

Before kick-off, Footalytics' live read gave Italy 41%, draw 28%, France 32%, most likely score 1-1 (13%), both teams to score 56%, over 2.5 goals 51%. The honest caveat first: the national teams have no rating on file, so this read uses a neutral default — a rough sketch, not a pick.

The model got the direction right — it leaned to the hosts. But it pictured a 1-1 stalemate, and the night delivered a 3-1 comeback. It underestimated two things: how fast Italy would respond to going behind, and how much France would miss a finisher — twice denied by the woodwork, with luck and finishing both a fraction short.

Why this one is worth remembering

  • Mbappé never played: the whole build-up was about "Mbappé is back", but a hamstring injury kept him out entirely. France's attack lost its sharpest finisher, and Olise's goal came from an opponent's mistake rather than the system working — what is wrong with France's attack without Mbappé?
  • A night for the Esposito brothers: Pio Esposito scored twice (26th minute, 75th-minute penalty) while his brother Sebastiano missed a penalty — between them, they owned every spot-kick storyline of the night. Pio, the Inter striker, is the first player to score at least eight goals in his first 14 appearances for Italy since Christian Vieri (1997–1998).
  • Zidane's first time chasing a game: 48 days in, four games unbeaten, France had never trailed under him until Thursday — and then they lost. Roberto Mancini put it plainly afterwards: Italy "deserved the victory", but "we need to go and win in Belgium" to keep top spot. The job is not done.
  • The table: Italy 10 points first, France 10 second, Belgium nine third, with the final round sending Italy to Belgium and France at home to Türkiye. Italy seal top spot by avoiding defeat; a France win almost certainly keeps them through, but first place will be decided on the last day.

What would change this call

  • The final round: Italy avoid defeat in Belgium and top spot is theirs; if Italy lose and France win, first place goes back to France. The 3-1 handed Italy the initiative, not the title.
  • Mbappé's hamstring: if he misses the Türkiye game too, France's attack stays dependent on Olise and company producing on the night; if he returns, France's ceiling changes immediately.
  • Zidane's response: how he reacts to a first defeat is the real first test of his tenure — in four unbeaten games, he had never lost before.

Talk about it

The model and the method

Footalytics predictions come from a Dixon-Coles Poisson model with Elo-style ratings. Every official pick is locked before kick-off and graded in public afterwards. See the latest numbers on the accuracy dashboard: 252 matches settled, 58.7% on win/draw/loss, Brier 0.581, 87.5% in the high-confidence tier (32 matches). The method is explained here. Match page: https://footalytics.farvor.com/match/nations-league-401861151-italy-vs-france

Try it on the next match

The model reads every fixture the same way — ask it about the next one, or check the public record first.

💬 Ask AI